Death's Door
Death's Door

Gail Lukasik

Reviewed by Cynthia Murphy

I am a big fan of mystery novels.  Ever since I discovered Nancy Drew books as a child, I have been hooked on mysteries.  As a result, I’ve become a bit of a snob.  I hate mysteries where the solutions seem obvious from the start.  That is definitely not the case with Gail Lukasik’s new novel, Death’s Door.  It offers all the action and plot twists that one would expect from a summer blockbuster.       

Lukasik actually starts her story 23 years earlier in Des Plaines, Illinois.  A reporter interviews a woman about her daughter’s sudden disappearance.  This scene is both intriguing and haunting.  The woman describes how her daughter seemed to vanish into thin air.  Lukasik quickly jumps into the modern action with the disappearance of another teenager.  The cases seem eerily similar, but the location is Door County, Wisconsin.  Lukasik shifts between the past and present to reveal both stories and their shocking connection.

Newspaper reporter Leigh Girard has to cover the story of the modern missing girl.  Leigh is a breast cancer survivor and relatively new to the area. Her editor tells her the story will probably end with the missing girl, Janell Margaris, returning on her own.  (Apparently, this is a common occurrence during the summer.)  It turns out that her editor is right; but the story doesn’t end there.  During the search for Janell, Leigh finds the body of Janell’s friend, Stephanie Everson.  The placement of the body is reminiscent of the case in Illinois.  The murder of Stephanie is just the tip off the iceberg.  Soon afterward, Leigh discovers another body.  Both girls look very similar, and they were both found near the Mink River.  The cases appear to be the work of a serial killer.

As the story progresses, the killer begins stalking Leigh.  She doesn’t fit the mold for his victims, but the killer seems to want her to know what he is doing.  At one point, Leigh even prints a plea to the killer in the newspaper.  Her efforts fail to stop the killer’s stalking.  Then the plot takes a shocking twist as Lukasik reveals the link between the current killings and the case described in the prologue.  It is a conclusion that keeps the reader on the edge of his seat.  I won’t spoil it, but it is definitely worth the wait.

Lukasik has an intriguing heroine in Leigh Girard.  Her fight against cancer has shaped her life.  It always seems to be in the back of her mind, but it isn’t a negative presence.  Instead, it seems to have given her a new type of courage.  That courage leads her to follow her hunches and ultimately solve the case.  Lukasik also does an excellent job of avoiding clichés with Leigh’s character.  It would have been very easy for her to fall into the trap of a clichéd crime-solving reporter.  Lukasik gives her character many dimensions and creates a unique voice for Leigh.

Lukasik also does a great job of creating suspense throughout the novel.  It is full of twists and turns that definitely keep the reader guessing.  Lukasik effectively maintains the suspense with the subplot that appears in the prologue.  It actually becomes an integral part of the main plot.  Lukasik skillfully weaves all of the connecting twists into one terrific suspenseful plot.

Death’s Door
is a must-read for mystery fans.  It has excellent pacing and a great heroine.  (It is actually the second novel featuring Leigh Girard.)  Gail Lukasik has a knack for creating suspense and maintaining the tension.  She has the foundation for a good series with the Leigh Girard mysteries.  Lukasik may still be relatively new to the mystery genre, but she could definitely be at the top of the field.

 Author Web Site

FRONT STREET REVIEWS HOME PAGE